America’s Rural/Urban Divide: Spotlight Oregon

The cultural gap between urban and rural Oregon is at the heart of political differences in the state, as is the case across the US.

On January 2, 2016, a group of armed militants seized and occupied the headquarters of the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge, an extensive tract of land located in a desolate area of Eastern Oregon. When I learned of this, I remember thinking to myself … Oregon? The state on the left coast that consistently had become a bastion of liberal democratic electoral success? That Oregon? How is it that a state known for its progressive leanings was now dealing with a group of disgruntled ranchers and militia-members, who were hell-bent on sending the federal government a message that they were sick and tired of being taken advantage of?

Back then, I was living in the Southern California desert in an area known as the Coachella Valley. Little did I know that in a few short months, when a long-planned retirement from the blue-collar world was about to commence, my wife was offered a dream job that was located in the Northern California coastal town of Crescent City, roughly a 30-minute drive south of the Oregon border.

To make a long story short, she accepted the offer, and we currently reside in the small coastal town of Brookings, Oregon. Just a stone’s throw from Crescent City, Brookings sits along the Pacific Ocean amid towering pines, picturesque mountain ranges, and magnificent rock formations. In short, it’s about as close to paradise as you can get.

But paradise is relative. It’s relative to the person making that claim. While there is so much to like here, there are contradictions and cultural norms that combine to create a climate of fear. A fear of others who may not look the same. Fear of changing demographics. Fear and resentment of federal and state governments. And, perhaps the biggest concern of them all: the end of white male dominance. To that end, Brookings, Oregon isn’t much different from the area in Eastern Oregon where the militia-members made their stand. Different in landscape? Yes. Different from social and cultural norms? Not so much.

And Portland may as well be thousands of miles away.

This dynamic … this division between urban/suburban areas and rural communities is playing out throughout the United States. It’s been happening for several years now, and the division only intensified since the election of the first African-American president in 2008. The election of Donald Trump has put it on steroids. Rural America is pissed.

Again, while Oregon is a consistent Democratic stronghold as far as elections go, it represents a microcosm of the great divide in America. And now that I’ve lived here for over two years, I decided to dig a little deeper into my new home state. Is there something in its history that might explain the divide? Is there something deeper … darker if you will … that lingers beneath all of this? Is there a racial and/or economic component?

Immigrants, African-Americans, and the Ku Klux Klan

Much to my surprise, as I began taking a look at Oregon’s history, especially the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, I noticed a demonization of immigrants and African-Americans that not only mirrored the deep South, but also the divisive rhetoric we’re still hearing today. Much of it early on was pointed at Chinese and Japanese immigrants who flocked to Oregon for the many jobs that were being created during construction of the transcontinental railroad. It didn’t take long for anti-Chinese immigrant sentiment to emerge. In fact, this negative sentiment prompted Congress to pass the Chinese Exclusion Act in 1882, which was the first law in the nation to deny naturalized citizenship to a specific nationality.

African-Americans also seized upon the new railroad construction as many flocked to the area to take jobs such as porters and dining-car waiters. So in a sense, the industrial revolution, coupled with the new railroad, attracted substantial numbers of non-white people to Oregon, which caused a significant backlash amongst the white majority who did not like the ‘invasion’ of minorities. Sound familiar?

Unfortunately, the backlash would continue for several years, and by the 1920’s, Oregon’s social and cultural life reflected a mostly homogeneous society, with social, cultural, and religious conformity at the forefront. Naturally, an organization like the Ku Klux Klan knew how to capitalize on such exclusivity and arrived on the scene in 1921. Shockingly, the Klan gained so much influence that they dominated the state legislature, with Klansman Kaspar K. Kubli even being elected speaker of the House. With Klan influence, several pieces of legislation passed that reflected anti-immigration sentiment.

Eventually, the Klan would wear out its welcome, but for several years in the 1920’s, their racist and divisive platform had ruled the day. I can’t help but think that some of the rhetoric and hate espoused by them had a profound effect on future generations of white Oregonians.

Portland
The rise of Portland

Much of the urban-rural divide in Oregon that still resonates today can be traced to the historical influence of its largest city, Portland. At the turn of the century, Portland was home to a quarter of Oregon’s population. Most of the influx of immigrants settled here, including Chinese, Japanese, Scandinavians, Germans, Irish, Russians, Italians, Filipinos, and Koreans. Also, Portland was the center of the African-American community as well.

With so many immigrants settling in the area, coupled with its unbridled economic dominance in the state, it’s no wonder many politicians from rural areas began to distrust Portland’s power-brokers. According to historian Earl Pomeroy, the tensions between urban and rural Oregon existed because “Portland was large enough to stimulate and arouse its neighbors, but not large enough to stifle them.” It’s pretty clear that these same sentiments exist in present-day Oregon. Even though Salem is the state capital, there’s no doubt that the real power in the state still resides in Portland … and the hate from rural Oregon continues unabated.

State of Jefferson

So now that I’ve established some historical perspective as to where some of Oregon’s urban-rural divide began, I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention the influence of pro-white/anti-government groups in the area. The history of Oregon is filled with stories of violent and racist groups. Communes, cults, alternative religious communities, and militias have been part of the state for generations. In fact, according to the New York Times, Oregon has been home to nearly 300 of them since 1856, including the Christian Identity movement, Posse Comitatus, Aryan Nations and the Roy Masters’ Foundation of Human Understanding. In fact, according to some historians, the state was primarily founded as a kind of white utopia.

So with that backdrop, it makes sense that there is a current movement taking place here that would establish a 51st state, which would encompass much of Northern California and rural southern Oregon. The newest state would be called the State of Jefferson.

Much of the State of Jefferson movement and the movement associated with the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge incident is similar. There is an inherent distrust of government. To put it in even simpler terms: These individuals are sick and tired of being told what to do by city slickers in Portland, Los Angeles, Sacramento, San Francisco and of course, Washington D.C. The State of Jefferson people, in particular, are riled over increases in taxes and fees generated by the federal government and ‘liberal’ statehouses in the big cities. The fact that most of these cities also are home to a diverse population surely has something to do with it as well, although they do not acknowledge it. Less government, fewer taxes, and freedom are what drives the movement they say.

I don’t doubt their sincerity. But the creation of a mostly white state with little regard for the rest of the country cannot be far from the goal here, in my opinion.

Final Thoughts

I’ve learned quite a bit about my new home state. I have to admit that the amount of racial hatred sprinkled throughout its history surprised me. I hadn’t realized the Ku Klux Klan had a presence here years ago. I had heard about the militia movements. And you can’t help but notice the State of Jefferson signs as you drive around the mostly rural areas of the state.

But even as rural America rebels against urban dominance, there are signs of the progressive nature of Oregon as well. For example, the first sign you see driving along Highway 101 from the Northern California border into Oregon is State Line Cannabis. In fact, in my small town of Brookings, we have approximately 8 cannabis dispensaries in operation. After Colorado and Washington became the first states to legalize recreational weed, Oregon was not far behind. Here in Brookings, while many lament the presence of weed dispensaries, most accept them. It brings in tax money and creates jobs … even conservative residents can appreciate that.

The people who live in Brookings respect one another. There’s not a lot of diversity to be sure, but neighbors help each other out, and there seems to be a genuine appreciation of this region: the clean air, pine-filled forests, pristine rivers, ocean, mountains, and so much more.

But while those things are real, so are the deep divisions. The political landscape continues to fracture along partisan and racial lines. The State of Jefferson movement isn’t going away anytime soon. Portland is and has been one of the most progressive big cities in the country, and its influence continues to grow.

As I sit here, looking out over the beautiful Pacific Ocean, I can’t help but wonder what lies ahead for Oregon. I’ll be here for a while. Maybe for the rest of my life actually. I have a feeling that progress will win out in the long run. Hopefully, inclusiveness will triumph over exclusivity. But, it’s not a given. Old habits, beliefs, and norms are hard to change.

Again, we see this playing out on a national scale as well. But perhaps the recent election is a forerunner of things to come for America. A much more diverse group of individuals will be heading to Washington in January. Texas nearly elected a charismatic progressive Senate candidate. Georgia, although still not officially over, nearly elected the nation’s first African-American woman as governor. Things are changing. I can feel it in the air.

I have my doubts that rural Oregon or the rest of rural America is on board.


Note: Many thanks to the Oregon Historical Society website for helping out with this post.

This article originally posted at onthefencevoters.com 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.